Connect with us

Education

When Luck Overrides Merit: The Controversial Lottery-Based Principal Appointments in Patna University

Rohan Priyadarshi

Published

on

Patna University


In a move that has sparked widespread debate, Patna University has appointed principals to five of its affiliated colleges through a lottery system — a method never before seen in such a significant academic context. While the university administration claims this was an effort to promote transparency and eliminate political or internal favoritism, many educationists, political leaders, and academics are questioning the logic, legality, and ethical soundness of such a process, especially for key leadership roles in higher education.

At the heart of the controversy is Dr. Suheli Mehta, the Head of the Home Science Department at Magadh Mahila College. An academic with a strong track record and placed at the top of the merit list, she was appointed principal of Commerce College, a much smaller institution and outside her subject expertise. Reportedly, Dr. Mehta is disappointed with the outcome and is hesitant to take charge of the position, choosing instead to continue in her current role. This has raised fundamental concerns over how administrative decisions are being made in one of Bihar’s oldest and most reputed universities.

The full list of appointments made through the lottery includes:

Dr. Suheli Mehta (Home Science, Magadh Mahila College) → Principal, Commerce College

Prof. Anil Kumar (Chemistry) → Principal, Patna College

Prof. Alka Yadav (Home Science) → Principal, Patna Science College

Prof. Nagendra Verma (History) → Principal, Magadh Mahila College

Prof. Yogendra Kumar Verma → Principal, Patna Law College


The appointments were made following a process initiated by the Bihar State University Service Commission (BSUSC), which had prepared a merit-based panel after interviews and scrutiny. However, instead of assigning principals to colleges based on qualifications and institutional needs, the final step — allotment of colleges — was done through a random draw. This, the authorities argue, was intended to maintain neutrality and prevent external influence, especially given the history of allegations around favoritism and political interference in college postings.

However, critics argue that while transparency is important, randomization undermines the principle of merit — especially in academia, where leadership and subject expertise play a vital role in shaping institutional quality. Educational institutions are not lottery booths, critics say, and reducing high-level academic appointments to chance weakens the very foundations of governance and planning in higher education.

One of the strongest criticisms came from BSP Chief Mayawati, who called it an attack on the dignity of education and demanded central government intervention. Student groups, teacher associations, and academics across Bihar echoed similar concerns. Many have called for a rollback of the appointments and a restructuring of the process based on academic alignment, leadership ability, and institution-specific needs.

In a significant development, the Patna High Court intervened on May 20, 2025, putting a temporary stay on the lottery-based appointment process. The court questioned the need for such a system in the case of principal appointments and sought clarification from the university and state education department. The next hearing was scheduled for June 16, but before the court could deliver a final verdict, the appointment orders were reportedly issued in early July. Whether this move violated court orders remains unclear.

The case of Dr. Suheli Mehta, in particular, exposes the flaws in the system. She is widely seen as one of the most deserving candidates — not only due to her subject matter expertise but also her administrative experience. Assigning her to a commerce-focused institution with little alignment to her academic background is being viewed as both a professional mismatch and a personal insult. Her reluctance to accept the position serves as a symbolic protest against the entire process.

At its core, this issue raises a larger question: Can chance ever be a substitute for competence? While transparency must be ensured, it cannot come at the cost of logical and educational suitability. By handing over such crucial appointments to a lottery, the university may have invited short-term neutrality but at the cost of long-term institutional stability.

In conclusion, Patna University’s experiment with a lottery-based appointment system has become a cautionary tale. It reflects the danger of overcorrecting for past administrative failures with simplistic solutions that may compromise academic integrity. As the matter continues to be debated in the courts and academic circles, it remains to be seen whether wisdom and merit will eventually find their rightful place in Bihar’s higher education landscape.

Roahn Priyadarshi is a journalist, content creator, and video editor with a passion for storytelling across digital platforms. With a sharp eye for detail and a creative approach to multimedia production, Roahn blends journalistic integrity with compelling visuals to engage and inform audiences. Whether reporting on current events, creating impactful video content, or crafting narratives for social media, he brings a dynamic and versatile voice to every project.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Admissions

UGC-NET December 2025 Notification Released: Registration Open, Exam Scheduled from December 31 to January 7

Prachi Sharma

Published

on

UGC-NET December 2025: Registration begins for the national eligibility exam — prepare now for Assistant Professor and JRF opportunities.

The National Testing Agency (NTA) has officially released the notification for the UGC-NET December 2025 examination. The registration process began on October 7, 2025, and will continue till November 7, 2025, through the official website ugcnet.nta.nic.in. Candidates will be allowed to make corrections in their submitted forms between November 10 and 12, 2025, as per the NTA schedule. The exam is scheduled to take place from December 31, 2025, to January 7, 2026, in Computer Based Test (CBT) mode across multiple cities in India.

According to the official NTA notice, the examination will be conducted for 85 subjects, assessing candidates for eligibility for Assistant Professorship and the Junior Research Fellowship (JRF). The UGC-NET remains one of the most competitive national-level exams in the higher education sector, serving as a crucial qualification for teaching and research positions in universities and colleges across India.

The application fee has been fixed at ₹ 1,150 for the General category, ₹ 600 for General-EWS and OBC-NCL candidates, and ₹ 325 for SC, ST, PwD, and Third-Gender applicants. Candidates are advised to verify their Aadhaar, UDID, and category certificates before applying to avoid any discrepancies during verification or later stages of the admission process.

NTA has also issued an advisory urging aspirants to ensure all personal and academic details are accurate while submitting the application form. Admit cards will be released closer to the exam date, followed by the result declaration tentatively in the last week of January 2026.

The UGC-NET exam consists of two papers — Paper 1 (General Teaching and Research Aptitude) and Paper 2 (Subject-specific). Both papers are conducted in a single session of three hours without any break. Candidates are advised to visit the official website regularly for updates on the admit card release and city intimation slip.

This year’s notification marks a major milestone for aspirants seeking academic and research careers in India. With registration now open, candidates are encouraged to complete the process before the last date to avoid last-minute issues and begin their final phase of preparation in earnest.

Continue Reading

Education

UGC NET December 2025: Latest Updates on Notification, Registration and Exam Date

Prachi Sharma

Published

on

The National Testing Agency (NTA) has released the notification for the Joint CSIR-UGC NET December 2025 examination, marking the beginning of the application process for aspiring researchers and lecturers. The registration window opened on 25 September 2025, and candidates can submit their applications online through the official website – csirnet.nta.nic.in.

According to the notification, the last date to apply is 24 October 2025 (till 11:50 PM), while the deadline to pay the examination fee is 25 October 2025. NTA has also provided an application correction window from 27 to 29 October 2025, allowing candidates to make necessary edits in their forms before the process closes.

The exam is scheduled for 18 December 2025 and will be conducted in computer-based test (CBT) mode. The paper will be held in two shifts – 9:30 AM to 12:00 PM and 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM, with each session lasting 180 minutes. Candidates will be able to download their city intimation slip and admit cards from the official portal in the weeks leading up to the exam.

The CSIR-UGC NET primarily assesses candidates in science and allied disciplines, including Life Sciences, Physical Sciences, Chemical Sciences, Mathematical Sciences, and Earth/Atmospheric/Planetary Sciences. Successful candidates may qualify for Junior Research Fellowship (JRF) or eligibility for appointment as Assistant Professor in Indian universities and colleges. While there is an upper age limit of 30 years for JRF aspirants, there is no age restriction for those applying only for Assistant Professor positions.

Meanwhile, the notification for the general UGC NET December 2025 cycle, which covers subjects in humanities, commerce, management, and social sciences, is still awaited. Aspirants are advised to keep a close watch on the official website ugcnet.nta.ac.in for the upcoming update.

With the December session now confirmed for the CSIR-UGC NET, experts suggest that candidates should begin or intensify their preparation, keeping in mind the prescribed syllabus and exam pattern, which remains largely unchanged from previous cycles. The December exam is seen as a crucial opportunity for thousands of postgraduates aiming to advance their careers in research and higher education.

Continue Reading

Education

UGC NET 2025 December Session Notification

Prachi Sharma

Published

on

The University Grants Commission National Eligibility Test (UGC NET) is one of India’s most prestigious examinations for aspiring academicians and researchers. Conducted by the National Testing Agency (NTA), this exam determines eligibility for the post of Assistant Professor and the award of the Junior Research Fellowship (JRF) in Indian universities and colleges. Over the years, UGC has also approved NET scores for PhD admissions, making the exam even more significant for students pursuing higher education.

The official notification for the UGC NET 2025 December session is expected to be released in September 2025. Once the schedule is announced, eligible candidates can register online through the official website, ugcnet.nta.ac.in. The application process will likely be open during October and November 2025, with an application correction window available within the same period. The examination itself is expected to be held in January 2026, conducted in two daily shifts — from 9:00 AM to 12:00 PM and 3:00 PM to 6:00 PM.

Before the exam, candidates will receive a city intimation slip, generally released 10 days before the test, which informs them of the city of their exam center. The admit card, containing the exact address and exam details, will be released about a week prior to the exam. The test will be conducted online in Computer-Based Test (CBT) mode across 83 subjects. It will consist of two papers, both held in a single three-hour session. Paper 1, common to all candidates, will assess teaching and research aptitude, while Paper 2 will focus on subject-specific knowledge. In total, there will be 150 multiple-choice questions carrying 300 marks, with no negative marking for incorrect answers.

The eligibility criteria for UGC NET require candidates to hold a master’s degree with at least 55% marks (50% for SC, ST, OBC, PwD, and EWS candidates). For the Junior Research Fellowship, the maximum age limit is 31 years with applicable relaxations, while there is no upper age limit for Assistant Professor eligibility. The application fee has been fixed at ₹1150 for General candidates, ₹650 for OBC/EWS, and ₹325 for SC/ST/PwD categories.

Results of the UGC NET are usually declared within two to three months of the exam. Qualified candidates are awarded an e-certificate, which remains valid for two years in the case of JRF and for a lifetime in the case of Assistant Professor eligibility. These certificates can be downloaded directly from the official UGC NET portal.

 

Continue Reading

Trending