After a string of less-than-stellar adaptations, one might understandably approach the new series, Jo Nesbø’s Detective Hole, with a degree of caution. Previous attempts, such as the critically panned Scarpettamisfire and the disappointing 2017 film adaptation of The Snowman—despite featuring Michael Fassbender as Nesbø’s tormented Oslo detective—had set a precedent for apprehension.
However, this Norwegian series, a compelling nine-episode saga, reintroduces viewers to Detective Harry Hole (Tobias Santelmann) with remarkable success. Created by Jo Nesbø himself, who also serves as writer and showrunner, this inaugural season is based on the fifth Harry Hole novel, The Devil’s Star (2003). Clocking in with episodes ranging from 43 to 62 minutes, it delivers a narrative that is both propulsive and intellectually sharp, ultimately doing justice to its gritty source material. The central storyline follows a troubled Oslo detective as he navigates a complex investigation into a serial killer, all while contending with a corrupt colleague.
Nesbø has often quipped that one of the liberties of adapting one’s own work is the freedom to disregard its original form. Yet, his directorial involvement ensures an exceptional translation of a dense novel into an absorbing series. This includes retaining the meticulous forensic details crucial to solving the cases. While largely faithful, the adaptation does feature one seemingly gratuitous killing that feels inexplicably tacked on.
The series masterfully weaves in elements from earlier Harry Hole books—specifically The Redbreast (2000) and Nemesis (2002)—to establish the protagonist’s complex backstory. The narrative opens with mercurial Detective Harry Hole (Tobias Santelmann) in relentless pursuit of a perpetrator involved in a string of violent bank robberies across Oslo. This chase tragically culminates in a death, plunging Harry into a deep abyss of despair, where he seeks solace at the bottom of a bottle. Five years later, Harry is portrayed as a high-functioning alcoholic, his life further complicated by the brutal murder of his closest friend and partner, Ellen (Ingrid Bolsø Berdal), during an arms smuggling investigation that hints at the involvement of high-ranking police officials.
Harry’s suspicions immediately fall upon the ambitious and ruthless policeman, Tom Waaler (Joel Kinnaman). Lacking concrete evidence, however, the police establishment is unwilling to act against one of their own. The scene is set during an unusually sweltering summer, when the majority of the police force is on vacation. Three seemingly unrelated murders send shockwaves through Oslo. Despite having received a termination notice for his drunken conduct at work, Harry’s unique insights into the cases compel the chief of police to reinstate him, even as Tom Waaler leads the official investigation. Harry embarks on a turbulent journey through a labyrinth of suspicion, grief, self-loathing, and doubt, as both ongoing investigations converge dramatically amidst a violent storm that finally breaks the oppressive heat.
Across the nine episodes, viewers are invited into the shadowy corners of Harry’s world, gaining insight into his eclectic views on subjects ranging from The Doors (“the most overrated band in history”) to elevators and diving. His fragile relationship with Rakel (Pia Tjelta) and her son, Oleg (Maxime Baune Bochud), introduces a tender human layer to a character otherwise consumed by self-destruction. Santelmann’s portrayal of Harry’s fractured brilliance and Kinnaman’s embodiment of Tom’s insidious menace establish them as formidable adversaries, delivering compelling performances.
The series features a truly exceptional soundtrack, blending timeless classics like Donovan’s ‘Season of the Witch,’ The Ramones’ ‘I Wanna Be Sedated,’ and ‘The End’ by The Doors with fresh, contemporary sounds. Nesbø’s own background as the lead vocalist and lyricist for a successful Norwegian rock band subtly permeates the show, notably in a tense sequence where Harry and a suspect bond over Iggy Pop songs starting with the letter ‘C’.
Nesbø has consistently emphasized Oslo’s integral role in the narrative, portraying it as more than just a backdrop. This is powerfully conveyed through breathtaking aerial shots, distinctive architectural elements, and expansive cityscapes that make the Norwegian capital feel like a living, breathing character within the story.